closing of three mile island

Page Contents

    Advertiser Disclosure: At ElectricityRates.com, our number one goal is to help you make better energy decisions. We adhere to strict editorial guidelines, however this post may include references to products offered from our partners.

    closing of three mile island

    Recently, the owner of Three Mile Island, the power plant associated with America’s all-time worst commercial nuclear accident, announced the nuclear plant will be closing at the end of September. While some are excited to see the plant closed, others are left wondering what will happen to their electricity bill.

    The good news is that the closing of TMI is not expected to impact electricity rates in PA in the near-term.

    The loss of TMI's capacity as of this October amounts to a reduction of about 804 megawatts from Pennsylvania's 2018 generating capacity of 44,753 MWs. That's a reduction of 1.8 percent.

    The state's peak demand for electricity, according to the Pennsylvania Public Utility Commission, requires approximately 30,000 MWs. This means that power supply should be no problem even with the closer of TMI.

    “There are no reliability issues, given the oversupply situation in PJM,” which covers Pennsylvania and all or parts of 12 other states.” –Christina Simeone, a senior fellow at the University of Pennsylvania's Kleinman Center for Energy Policy,

    Electricity rates in PA should also stay stable, if not decrease, in the short-term.

    Pennsylvania Public Utility Commission Chair Gladys Brown Dutrieuille told state House members Monday that "if the lost nuclear capacity is replaced by natural gas-fueled generation, which is the likely outcome, wholesale energy prices would decrease in a range of 9 percent to 24 percent each year over the next three years."

    These predictions were based on the loss of both Three Mile Island and Beaver Valley, a nuclear plant in western Pennsylvania that could close in 2021, as well as market forecasts that anticipate only slight increases in natural gas prices through the next several years.

    In conclusion, PA residents shouldn’t be too worried about electricity rates going up due to the closure of TMI. The state is still producing more than enough power to keep electricity prices stable.

    In fact, ElectricityRates.com has savings in many of the utility areas in PA that you can find below.

    Pennsylvania

    Price to Compare 10.53¢

    The electricity utility's price for electricity supply expressed as a price per kWh, to be used to contrast prices with competitive suppliers.

    Best Electricity Rates
    ProviderPlan NameLengthRate Per kWhSign Up
    Clearview Energy
    Clear Guarantee 6
    6 Mo.8.39¢
    Save 21%
    Select
    Tomorrow Energy
    12 Month Fixed
    12 Mo.8.59¢
    Save 19%
    Select
    APG&E
    True Classic 6
    6 Mo.9.19¢
    Save 13%
    Select
    Clearview Energy
    Clear Guarantee 24
    24 Mo.10.79¢Select
    Constellation
    24 Month Green Home Power Plan
    24 Mo.12.39¢Select
    PlanRate Per kWh
    Clearview Energy
    Clear Guarantee 6

    6 Months
    8.39¢
    Select
    Tomorrow Energy
    12 Month Fixed

    12 Months
    8.59¢
    Select
    APG&E
    True Classic 6

    6 Months
    9.19¢
    Select
    Clearview Energy
    Clear Guarantee 24

    24 Months
    10.79¢
    Select
    Constellation
    24 Month Green Home Power Plan

    24 Months
    12.39¢
    Select
    • 100% Renewable Sources
    See All Plans

    Pennsylvania

    Price to Compare 11.31¢

    The electricity utility's price for electricity supply expressed as a price per kWh, to be used to contrast prices with competitive suppliers.

    Best Electricity Rates
    ProviderPlan NameLengthRate Per kWhSign Up
    Clearview Energy
    Clear Guarantee 6
    6 Mo.8.79¢
    Save 23%
    Select
    APG&E
    True Classic 6
    6 Mo.9.28¢
    Save 18%
    Select
    APG&E
    True Classic Green 8
    8 Mo.9.88¢
    Save 13%
    Select
    APG&E
    True Classic 24
    24 Mo.10.58¢
    Save 7%
    Select
    Constellation
    36 Month PowerPlug Plan
    36 Mo.12.29¢Select
    PlanRate Per kWh
    Clearview Energy
    Clear Guarantee 6

    6 Months
    8.79¢
    Select
    APG&E
    True Classic 6

    6 Months
    9.28¢
    Select
    APG&E
    True Classic Green 8

    8 Months
    9.88¢
    Select
    APG&E
    True Classic 24

    24 Months
    10.58¢
    Select
    Constellation
    36 Month PowerPlug Plan

    36 Months
    12.29¢
    Select
    • 100% Renewable Sources
    • Smart Home System Included
    See All Plans

    Pennsylvania

    Sorry, we don't offer residential electricity rates for the selected options.

    Pennsylvania

    Price to Compare 9.27¢

    The electricity utility's price for electricity supply expressed as a price per kWh, to be used to contrast prices with competitive suppliers.

    Best Electricity Rates
    ProviderPlan NameLengthRate Per kWhSign Up
    Clearview Energy
    Clear Guarantee 6
    6 Mo.6.69¢
    Save 28%
    Select
    Tomorrow Energy
    12 Month Fixed
    12 Mo.7.18¢
    Save 23%
    Select
    Tomorrow Energy
    9 Month Fixed
    9 Mo.7.18¢
    Save 23%
    Select
    Direct Energy
    Live Brighter 18
    18 Mo.9.19¢
    Save 1%
    Select
    Constellation
    36 Month PowerPlug Plan
    36 Mo.10.99¢Select
    PlanRate Per kWh
    Clearview Energy
    Clear Guarantee 6

    6 Months
    6.69¢
    Select
    Tomorrow Energy
    12 Month Fixed

    12 Months
    7.18¢
    Select
    Tomorrow Energy
    9 Month Fixed

    9 Months
    7.18¢
    Select
    Direct Energy
    Live Brighter 18

    18 Months
    9.19¢
    Select
    Constellation
    36 Month PowerPlug Plan

    36 Months
    10.99¢
    Select
    • 100% Renewable Sources
    • Smart Home System Included
    See All Plans

    Pennsylvania

    Price to Compare 10.04¢

    The electricity utility's price for electricity supply expressed as a price per kWh, to be used to contrast prices with competitive suppliers.

    Best Electricity Rates
    ProviderPlan NameLengthRate Per kWhSign Up
    Clearview Energy
    Clear Guarantee 6
    6 Mo.9.09¢
    Save 10%
    Select
    APG&E
    True Classic 13
    13 Mo.9.48¢Select
    Tomorrow Energy
    12 Month Fixed
    12 Mo.9.49¢
    Save 6%
    Select
    APG&E
    True Classic 24
    24 Mo.10.88¢Select
    Constellation
    36 Month PowerPlug Plan
    36 Mo.12.49¢Select
    PlanRate Per kWh
    Clearview Energy
    Clear Guarantee 6

    6 Months
    9.09¢
    Select
    APG&E
    True Classic 13

    13 Months
    9.48¢
    Select
    Tomorrow Energy
    12 Month Fixed

    12 Months
    9.49¢
    Select
    APG&E
    True Classic 24

    24 Months
    10.88¢
    Select
    Constellation
    36 Month PowerPlug Plan

    36 Months
    12.49¢
    Select
    • 100% Renewable Sources
    • Smart Home System Included
    See All Plans

    Pennsylvania

    Price to Compare 10.61¢

    The electricity utility's price for electricity supply expressed as a price per kWh, to be used to contrast prices with competitive suppliers.

    Best Electricity Rates
    ProviderPlan NameLengthRate Per kWhSign Up
    Clearview Energy
    Clear Guarantee 6
    6 Mo.8.69¢
    Save 19%
    Select
    APG&E
    True Classic 12
    12 Mo.9.28¢Select
    APG&E
    True Classic 6
    6 Mo.9.28¢
    Save 13%
    Select
    Direct Energy
    Live Brighter™ 18
    18 Mo.10.19¢
    Save 4%
    Select
    Constellation
    24 Month Green Home Power Plan
    24 Mo.11.29¢Select
    PlanRate Per kWh
    Clearview Energy
    Clear Guarantee 6

    6 Months
    8.69¢
    Select
    APG&E
    True Classic 12

    12 Months
    9.28¢
    Select
    APG&E
    True Classic 6

    6 Months
    9.28¢
    Select
    Direct Energy
    Live Brighter™ 18

    18 Months
    10.19¢
    Select
    Constellation
    24 Month Green Home Power Plan

    24 Months
    11.29¢
    Select
    • 100% Renewable Sources
    See All Plans

    Pennsylvania

    Price to Compare 11.23¢

    The electricity utility's price for electricity supply expressed as a price per kWh, to be used to contrast prices with competitive suppliers.

    Best Electricity Rates
    ProviderPlan NameLengthRate Per kWhSign Up
    Tomorrow Energy
    12 Month Fixed
    12 Mo.9.39¢
    Save 17%
    Select
    Energy Harbor
    Safe Harbor 12
    12 Mo.9.98¢
    Save 12%
    Select
    Constellation
    12 Month Home Power Plan
    12 Mo.10.29¢
    Save 9%
    Select
    Energy Harbor
    Safe Harbor 32
    32 Mo.10.99¢
    Save 3%
    Select
    Constellation
    36 Month PowerPlug Plan
    36 Mo.11.89¢Select
    PlanRate Per kWh
    Tomorrow Energy
    12 Month Fixed

    12 Months
    9.39¢
    Select
    Energy Harbor
    Safe Harbor 12

    12 Months
    9.98¢
    Select
    Constellation
    12 Month Home Power Plan

    12 Months
    10.29¢
    Select
    Energy Harbor
    Safe Harbor 32

    32 Months
    10.99¢
    Select
    Constellation
    36 Month PowerPlug Plan

    36 Months
    11.89¢
    Select
    • 100% Renewable Sources
    • Smart Home System Included
    See All Plans
    Pennsylvania

    Price to Compare 10.00¢

    The electricity utility's price for electricity supply expressed as a price per kWh, to be used to contrast prices with competitive suppliers.

    Best Electricity Rates
    ProviderPlan NameLengthRate Per kWhSign Up
    Clearview Energy
    Clear Guarantee 6
    6 Mo.7.49¢
    Save 26%
    Select
    APG&E
    True Classic 6
    6 Mo.7.98¢Select
    Tomorrow Energy
    12 Month Fixed
    12 Mo.8.69¢
    Save 14%
    Select
    Direct Energy
    Live Brighter™ 18
    18 Mo.8.99¢
    Save 11%
    Select
    Constellation
    36 Month PowerPlug Plan
    36 Mo.10.69¢Select
    PlanRate Per kWh
    Clearview Energy
    Clear Guarantee 6

    6 Months
    7.49¢
    Select
    APG&E
    True Classic 6

    6 Months
    7.98¢
    Select
    Tomorrow Energy
    12 Month Fixed

    12 Months
    8.69¢
    Select
    Direct Energy
    Live Brighter™ 18

    18 Months
    8.99¢
    Select
    Constellation
    36 Month PowerPlug Plan

    36 Months
    10.69¢
    Select
    • 100% Renewable Sources
    • Smart Home System Included
    See All Plans

    However, it is important to remember that generating nuclear energy is carbon-free and that currentlynuclear provides more than 90 percent of the all the zero-carbon energy produced in Pennsylvania. Any near-term drop in nuclear generation here will most likely be picked up by burning more natural gas which, while cleaner than coal, is still a fossil fuel and would in fact add to Pennsylvania's carbon loading and undermine progress the state has made in reducing greenhouse gas emissions over the last decade.